Top-Performing Airbnb Listings in Lancaster, United States

Updated October 2026 · Data period: Sep 2025–Sep 2026

Compare 30 leading Airbnb listings in Lancaster, ranked by the Airbtics Listing Score, a score out of 100 based on guest reviews, Guest Favorite status, and occupancy compared with the market median over the same period. See guest ratings, occupancy, average daily rates, and estimated annual revenue for each property.

Listings are ranked by the Airbtics Listing Score, a score out of 100 based on guest reviews, Guest Favorite status, and occupancy over the last 12 months.

How the score works

Factor Maximum points
Guest rating (vs. a 4.3 floor)30
Guest Favorite badge30
Occupancy (last 12 months)30
Operating scale (listing-months)10

When listings tie on the same score, the listing with more guest reviews ranks higher — a larger review history gives stronger evidence of sustained performance.

Revenue and nightly rate are shown separately so you can compare commercial performance alongside the score. This leaderboard highlights strong guest experience and booking performance — not the market’s highest earners by revenue alone.

Lancaster Airbnb market at a glance

Listings tracked Median occupancy Median daily rate Median annual revenue
1,356 61% $193 $45,436

Market figures cover Sep 2025–Sep 2026 and provide context for the leaderboard below. See the full Lancaster Market Overview →

Top 30 Airbnb listings in Lancaster

Ranked by Listing Score among the 1,356 active Airbnb listings Airbtics tracks in Lancaster. When listings tie on the same score, the one with more guest reviews ranks higher.

Rank Listing Scoreout of 100 Airbnb listing Guest rating Occupancy Average daily rate Estimated annual revenue Listing Insights
#1 90
Comfortable one bedroom with parking
1 BR · Entire rental unit · Lancaster
4.9
600 reviews
85–100% $68 $22,882 View listing
#2 90
Studio Apt full of amenities, cozy and quaint
1 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
4.9
465 reviews
85–100% $66 $19,218 View listing
#3 90 4.9
384 reviews
85–100% $139 $45,525 View listing
#4 90
Waterfront Log Cabin with Hot Tub
1 BR · Entire place · Lancaster
5.0
288 reviews
85–100% $375 $109,988 View listing
#5 90
Conowingo Creek Casual
1 BR · Entire guest suite · Lancaster
5.0
221 reviews
85–100% $138 $42,211 View listing
#6 90
Historic School house|SAUNA|Hot Tub|Fire Pit|Grill
3 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
5.0
220 reviews
81% $313 $97,738 View listing
#7 90
Private suite with kitchenette
Studio BR · Entire guest suite · Lancaster
5.0
191 reviews
83% $61 $16,809 View listing
#8 90
Modern. Luxury Creekside Cabin. Hot Tub. Firepit.
3 BR · Entire cabin · Lancaster
5.0
175 reviews
85–100% $375 $122,332 View listing
#9 90
Iconic "Shoe House" w/ Hot Tub, Firepit & Arcade!
3 BR · Entire place · Lancaster
5.0
175 reviews
85–100% $424 $152,021 View listing
#10 90
The Apartment At Baumgardner
2 BR · Entire rental unit · Lancaster
4.9
167 reviews
85–100% $127 $39,698 View listing
#11 90
The Creek House: Waterfront with Hot Tub & E-bikes
2 BR · Entire cabin · Lancaster
5.0
140 reviews
83% $356 $104,304 View listing
#12 90
The Safe Harbor House/with a view
3 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
5.0
113 reviews
82% $250 $43,820 View listing
#13 90
Maple Lane
3 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
5.0
107 reviews
85–100% $205 $49,369 View listing
#14 90
The Willow Street Cottage/quiet & peaceful
2 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
4.9
104 reviews
80% $186 $45,751 View listing
#15 90
The Farmhouse at The Jack
4 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
4.8
78 reviews
85% $244 $51,156 View listing
#16 90
Spacious Basement Studio (Private Entrance)
1 BR · Entire rental unit · Lancaster
5.0
69 reviews
85–100% $94 $13,088 View listing
#17 90
York area home with a Peaceful View
1 BR · Entire guest suite · Lancaster
5.0
44 reviews
84% $114 $26,909 View listing
#18 90 4.8
38 reviews
85–100% $81 $7,854 View listing
#19 90
The Grand Room Spacious 1 BDR Suite near DT
1 BR · Entire rental unit · Lancaster
4.9
36 reviews
85–100% $117 $12,952 View listing
#20 90
Family Friendly AFrame w/Pool & Amish Country View
3 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
5.0
32 reviews
85–100% $552 $51,176 View listing
#21 90
Luxury studio apartment with stunning views
Studio BR · Entire rental unit · Lancaster
5.0
13 reviews
85–100% $100 $10,350 View listing
#22 90
Private River View Retreat~ Over looking the River
3 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
4.9
13 reviews
85–100% $290 $23,751 View listing
#23 90
Elegant Secluded Guest Cottage in Lancaster
2 BR · Entire cottage · Lancaster
5.0
9 reviews
85–100% $73 $7,945 View listing
#24 89
small studio apartment
1 BR · Private room · Lancaster
5.0
338 reviews
76% $52 $14,945 View listing
#25 89
The Conestoga Cottage (hot tub; close to city)
3 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
4.9
246 reviews
77% $210 $63,300 View listing
#26 89
The Trolley House / Romantic getaway
1 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
5.0
187 reviews
78% $202 $58,597 View listing
#27 89
~The Pretty Peacock~
2 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
5.0
169 reviews
78% $163 $44,019 View listing
#28 89
Quiet Home on Main St Near All
4 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
5.0
21 reviews
78% $233 $59,247 View listing
#29 88
Home has fireplace, kitchen, fire pit, 6 mile-Lanc
1 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
5.0
99 reviews
74% $119 $34,304 View listing
#30 88
There's No Place Like Peyton Place
3 BR · Entire home · Lancaster
5.0
82 reviews
75% $171 $48,763 View listing

Data note: Every featured listing held Airbnb’s Guest Favorite badge as of 2026-10-29. Occupancy above 85% is shown as 85–100%. Revenue, occupancy and daily rates are Airbtics estimates for the stated data period.

Data Seen By

Explore listings in Lancaster

Compare the 1,356 listings tracked in Lancaster. Filter by property type, review revenue history, and build your own comp set in the Airbtics app.

Explore Lancaster listings →

Lancaster Airbnb listing FAQs

  • Which are the top-performing Airbnb listings in Lancaster?

    Comfortable one bedroom with parking ranks first on this leaderboard with a Listing Score of 90 out of 100. It has a 4.9 guest rating from 600 reviews and an estimated occupancy rate above 85% during Sep 2025–Sep 2026. The table shows how it compares with the other featured listings.

  • How are the listings ranked?

    Listings are ranked by the Airbtics Listing Score, which considers guest reviews, Guest Favorite status, and occupancy compared with similar local properties. When listings tie on the same score, the listing with more guest reviews ranks higher. To qualify, a listing must meet Airbnb rating data, at least 90 active days in the last 12 months, and occupancy data available.

    The score evaluates the combination of guest experience and booking performance. Revenue and nightly rate are shown separately so you can compare commercial performance alongside the score.

    Read the full scoring methodology →

  • How much do these Airbnb listings earn?

    Among the 30 featured listings with revenue estimates, estimated annual revenue ranges from $7,854 to $152,021, with a median of $43,919, during Sep 2025–Sep 2026.

    These figures describe the listings featured on this leaderboard. For a broader view, see Airbnb revenue across Lancaster.

  • How does their occupancy compare with the market?

    The featured listings with occupancy estimates have a median occupancy rate above 85%, compared with 61% across Lancaster during Sep 2025–Sep 2026.

    Listing occupancy above 85% is shown as a band (85–100%) rather than an exact figure.

  • What does Guest Favorite mean?

    Guest Favorite is an Airbnb badge identifying homes that stand out based on ratings, reviews and reliability. It applies to an individual listing.

    Every listing featured on this leaderboard held the Guest Favorite badge as of 2026-10-29. Learn how Airbnb identifies Guest Favorites →

  • Can I use these listings as Airbnb comps?

    Use the leaderboard to discover properties worth investigating, then choose comps that match your property’s location, bedrooms, property type and amenities. Include a wider range of comparable properties when estimating expected revenue, because this leaderboard highlights leading listings.

    You can filter listings and build your own comp set in the Airbtics app.

  • Can I see the historical data behind a listing?

    Open Listing Insights to review the property’s historical revenue, occupancy and nightly rates. You can also inspect calendar snapshots showing the availability and prices recorded over time.

    Explore listing-level data in Lancaster →

Review monthly performance for each listing

See up to three years of estimated monthly revenue, occupancy and nightly rates for an individual listing. Investigate how its performance changes through the seasons and how it compares with the wider market. If you have an address in mind, use our calculator to estimate income for a specific property.

Monthly revenue, occupancy and average daily rate for an individual Airbnb listing in Airbtics.
Monthly revenue, occupancy and nightly rate for one listing.

Inspect the calendar observations behind the estimates

Review calendar snapshots from the last 12 months to see which nights were available or unavailable when Airbtics checked, along with the prices recorded for available nights.

An unavailable night can reflect a booking or an owner block. The snapshots give you a record of the observed calendar, so you can inspect the evidence alongside the estimated performance.

Historical coverage varies by listing.

Historical Airbnb calendar snapshots showing observed availability and nightly prices in Airbtics.
Calendar snapshots: observed availability and nightly prices.