Five Star Property Company Profile: Airbnb Reviews, Listings & Performance in Indianapolis
Data note
These figures are estimates based on Airbtics' tracked Airbnb and short-term rental data. Actual occupancy, ADR, revenue, and listing counts may differ from a company's internal PMS or owner reports. We have refined this methodology over 6 years and use our best effort to keep the data accurate and useful.
Which listings do Five Star Property manage?
Five Star Property manage a total of 61 listings: 21 listings in Potrero-Flamingo, 15 listings in Tamarindo, 13 listings in Indianapolis and 1 listing in Louisville, plus 11 listings across other markets.
| Market | Listings | Rank | Host Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Potrero-Flamingo | 21 | #22 of 38 | 50 |
| Tamarindo | 15 | #89 of 194 | 62 |
| Indianapolis | 13 | #54 of 122 | 56 |
| Louisville | 1 | #3 of 107 | 80 |
| Other markets | 11 | — | — |
| Total (company-wide) | 61 | — | — |
How we count listings: we only include properties with enough booking history to measure — in practice, listings that were available for booking for at least 3 months of the last 365 days, or that appeared in our most recent monthly refresh. Listings that only open for a short period can drop out. A market is also shown on its own only when a company has 5 or more tracked listings there, so smaller footprints are grouped under “Other markets”.
Associated Airbnb profiles
These are the Airbnb host pages that are linked to Five Star Property.
- Ohana Vacations (primary) — 40 listings
- John — 21 listings
Five Star Property Airbnb listings in Indianapolis, United States
Host Score 56 · Rank #54 of 122 companies
Map shows 13 geocoded listings in Indianapolis. Hover a pin for average daily rate and bedroom count.
Listings preview
| Listing | Type | Beds | ADR | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Urban Luxury | Walkable | Easy Parking | Spacious! | Entire home | 4 BR | $287 | 4.8 (104) |
| Beech Grove Retreat | Private Yard • Game Floor! | Entire home | 4 BR | $199 | 4.8 (126) |
| New Downtown Apartment | Next to Motor Speedway! | Entire home | 1 BR | $154 | 5.0 (78) |
| Modern Cottage | Near State Fairgrounds | Backyard | Entire home | 3 BR | $202 | 4.8 (51) |
| Family Retreat mins to Children's Museum | Entire home | 4 BR | $292 | 4.5 (75) |
| Spacious 4BR Home | Downtown Indy | Walkable | Entire home | 4 BR | $262 | 4.5 (14) |
| Downtown Indy Gem | Quiet Street | Ideal Location! | Entire home | 2 BR | $170 | 4.9 (45) |
| Chic Modern 2BR Retreat w/ Yard, Laundry & SmartTV | Entire home | 2 BR | $152 | 4.8 (24) |
Top Alternatives to Five Star Property
The highest-scoring Airbnb hosts in Indianapolis, United States, based on the same Host Score used on this page. Or browse every host in Indianapolis.
Similar Airbnb Hosts (by Host Score)
Other verified Airbnb Hosts in Indianapolis with a similar Host Score profile.
-
- Host Score: 62
- Rating: 4.9
- Listings: 13
-
- Host Score: 63
- Rating: 5
- Listings: 23
-
- Host Score: 60
- Rating: 4.7
- Listings: 54
-
- Host Score: 58
- Rating: 4.9
- Listings: 11
-
- Host Score: 56
- Rating: 4.8
- Listings: 33
Five Star Property Airbnb Guest Reviews
Five Star Property has an average rating on Airbnb of 4.8. This Airbnb rating shows that Five Star Property consistently delivers excellent property management services, ensuring strong guest satisfaction and trust.
Everything was neat and beautiful
Great place to spend with family and friends
We got to also got see wildlife during out visit in the property!
Frequently asked questions about Five Star Property
-
How much does Five Star Property charge for Airbnb management?
The average Indianapolis Airbnb property manager charges 10–15% of short-term rental income for half-service management and 20–30% for full-service management. Premium managers may charge up to 40–45% of the booking total. Contact Five Star Property directly for a custom quote.
-
Is Five Star Property a good Airbnb property manager in Indianapolis?
Considering Five Star Property's fees, portfolio size, and performance vs the Indianapolis market average, it can be a fit for hosts who want professional short-term rental management in Indianapolis. Compare costs and expected revenue uplift before signing.
-
How many listings does Five Star Property manage?
Five Star Property has 61 listings tracked company-wide in the Airbtics directory.
-
Which markets does Five Star Property operate in?
Five Star Property has ranked market coverage in: Potrero-Flamingo, Tamarindo, Indianapolis, Louisville.
-
Can I claim and edit the Five Star Property profile?
Yes. Open the Five Star Property host profile in the Airbtics app, sign in or create a free account, and request ownership verification there. Once we have confirmed that you own or work for Five Star Property, you can edit the company name, link other Airbnb host profiles to this page, and add your website and social media links. Performance figures such as occupancy, ADR and revenue are produced by our own tracking and cannot be edited yet.